‘Jagged Little Pill’ Star Lauren Patten’s Tony Award Win Ignites Outrage
Star of “Jagged Little Pill,” Lauren Patten, took home a Tony on Sunday for Best Actress in a Musical, but her win sparked an internet firestorm.
Patten’s award comes as the Actors’ Equity Association announced on Sunday that it had launched an independent investigation into the production after former cast members alleged that management intimidated and forced them to delay critical surgery. Actors Nora Schell and Celia Rose Gooding have claimed that the workplace was harmful to the trans and non-binary community onstage and off.
In accepting her Tony, Patten acknowledged the controversy around the show. “It is also a strange time for awards,” she said. “We are in the middle of a reckoning in our industry. And first and foremost I want to thank my trans and nonbinary friends and colleagues who have engaged with me in difficult conversations that have joined me in dialogue about my character Jo.”
She added, “I believe that the future for the change we need to see on Broadway comes from these kinds of conversations that are full of honesty and empathy and respect for our shared humanity.”
But critics on social media were disappointed by her win, with some suggesting she should have dropped out of the show and declined the award, considering the accusations the production was facing.
that lauren patten would accept that award just bears testament to the fact that no amount of “accountability conversations” can change how she believes her entitlement to play that role is more important than what any trans person feels
— raya (@intoanewlife) September 26, 2021
if lauren patten actually believed what she said, she would drop out of the show and decline the award.
— Gage Tarlton (@gaygetarlton) September 26, 2021
the fact that jlp posted that wordy “apology” (with no acknowledgement or direct apology for what iris and nora went through by the way), while lauren patten is still returning to the role shows that they still don’t care about us but hey
— maya ミ☆ loves nai (@KLAlNTANA) September 18, 2021
interesting take for lauren patten to talk about “difficult conversations” with trans and non-binary people but to continue to play a role in the show as it actively hurts these exact people… bestie leave the show
— maybe eli… maybe not tho (@gendrlesscowboy) September 26, 2021
Schell said on social media Friday that they were repeatedly “intimidated, coerced, and forced by multiple higher ups to put off critical and necessary surgery to remove growths from my vagina that were making me anemic.”
She said that they were told by the gynecologist that they needed polycystic ovarian syndrome surgery, but the stage manager and creative team disregarded this. “When I relayed the possibility of these growths returning/needing surgery again in the future, I was met with exasperation and told that if I had to take off, it wouldn’t be considered paid medical leave.”
Schell said they don’t plan on returning to the show in October when it reopens, and Gooding announced that her performance on Sunday’s Tony Awards will be her last as Frankie Healy.
